Comparing Fielding Awards

Posted by Behr on Nov 3, 2011 in Featured Story

I like to talk. I like to talk a lot. Most of the time, I have things worth saying. Sometimes, it just flies right over people’s heads. Regardless of what I’m saying, how I’m saying it never comes out quite perfect. Doesn’t matter whether I’m talking baseball or chatting with a babe from the SU Volleyball team (which, come on folks, it’s clear there isn’t much of a difference for me at this point), the chances I exactly what I want to say are not high.

However, this is not the case with statistics.

Elite Defenders is one of many projects already underway at FoI that allows statistics to speak for both us and speak up for themselves. I’ve sat down with my buddy Tom Barrile countless times this semester, arguing for hours on end whether or not baseball is the superior sport over football (obviously, as everyone deep-down knows, it is). What we CAN’T ARGUE is the number of television viewers that watch the MLB postseason compared to the NFL playoffs.

The Constant Gardner

Posted by Behr on Nov 3, 2011 in Blurbs

Before I go further, let it be known: I refuse to fall into the trap that hundreds of baseball bloggers have fallen into by becoming too “emotionally involved” with these various fielding awards. Awards are essentially handed out to ensure that more people are heading home happy, more people are heading home as winners. If there can only be one World Series ball club, baseball wants to make sure it’s marketing all of its superstars appropriately.

Having said that … Let’s pray you don’t find a bigger snub this offseason than outfielder Brett Gardner missing out on a GG achievement. This may not be seen as a crime against humanity, but it should certainly be considered a crime against the baseball community.

Field of Ignorance’s 2011 Elite Defenders

Posted by Behr on Nov 1, 2011 in Featured Story

In September of 2006, PROTRADE.com (a ‘sports stock market’ website) released an article on their picks for the Gold Glove winners that season. In the article, the PROTRADE staff wrote that “traditional fielding statistics don’t measure range, perhaps the most important trait of a solid glove man. Errors tell us how a player does when they get to the ball — but what about when he doesn’t?”

PROTRADE used a system that measured the direction and distance of every hit so as to compare every fielder’s performance with the historical averages at that ballpark. Their statistic was (ironically enough, given the name Moneyball Fielding Runs (or MBF).

Five years later, the baseball community has two stats PROTRADE could not work with: Ultimate Zone Rating and Defensive Runs Saved. According to our friends at FanGraphs.com, UZR puts “a run value to defense, attempting to quantify how many runs a player saved or gave up through their fielding prowess” while DRS “captures a player’s total defensive value … comparable to UZR.”